The Old Taylor Can’t Come to the Phone

On the night of August 18, 2017, Taylor Swift wiped her Instagram.

She had 102 million followers. For a decade she had been one of the most consistently present performers in the world — the Fourth of July parties, the squad videos, the carefully curated life of America’s pop sweetheart.

Then, over the course of one evening, every photograph, every caption, every piece of that decade-long public self disappeared. The grid went blank.

Three days later, a short video appeared. A black-and-white clip of a snake. Coiled, tongue flicking, sliding into the frame.

She was eighty-four days from releasing her sixth album. The year before, she had been publicly humiliated in a feud that ended with much of the internet calling her a liar. The court of public opinion had delivered its verdict: snake.

What the world did not know, watching that blank grid and that coiled snake, was that they were watching something older than Taylor Swift. Older than Instagram. Older than the music industry. They were watching a pattern the universe has been running since before there were galaxies.

They were watching a death. And three days later, a rising.

✦

The album she released that November was called Reputation. It opens with Look What You Made Me Do — industrial percussion and bare-bones synth that sounds like nothing she had ever recorded. Halfway through, the music drops away. There is the sound of a phone being dialed. A spoken voice, dry and theatrical, says:

I’m sorry. The old Taylor can’t come to the phone right now.

A pause.

Why? Oh — ’cause she’s dead.

She announced, on the lead single of a forty-five-minute album, that the person everybody thought they knew was dead. Not retired. Not rebranded. Dead. The word choice is deliberate, and it is not safe. You do not open a pop album by announcing your own death unless you are reaching for something.

The album that follows is a journey through that death. Songs about what destroyed the old self — the weaponized narratives, the out-of-context quotes, the public crucifixion by hashtag. Songs from inside the grave — the rage, the paranoia, the vengeful drafts of emails nobody was ever going to send.

And then, deep in the second half, something changes. The tempo softens. The production opens up. The voice becomes a voice you have not heard before — quieter, steadier, more grown-up. By the closing track, New Year’s Day, she is singing about a small, ordinary love.

I want your midnights. But I’ll be cleaning up bottles with you on New Year’s Day.

The dragons are still there. She does not pretend they were not real. She carried the wounds — the dragon-marks — into the new life. But the new life is a new life.

✦

Taylor Swift was not trying to preach a sermon. She was trying to survive. She would probably be embarrassed to hear her album called a theological document. But survival, when it is honest enough, sounds like the gospel. Because the pattern she was walking through is the pattern the universe was built on.

✦

Paul writes to the Romans, sometime around the year 56, from the city of Corinth.

Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life.

Romans chapter six. Most sermons treat it as a metaphor about baptism — the symbolism of going under the water and coming back up. But Paul is not talking about symbolism. He is describing a mechanism. The death-and-resurrection pattern Jesus walked through is now the pattern every human life is shaped by.

The old self genuinely dies. The new self genuinely rises. And — this is the line most people skip — the new self is not the old self restored. It is something new. Something that could not have existed on the other side of the death without the death actually happening.

You cannot skip the dying. There is no resurrection shortcut. The tree is in the middle of the map and every road runs through it.

✦

This is what Reputation is about, even though Reputation does not know it.

The old Taylor genuinely died. The new Taylor genuinely rose. The new Taylor is not the old Taylor with her reputation repaired. She is a different person, carrying the wounds of the old Taylor into a life the old Taylor could not have lived.

The album is not preaching the gospel. But the shape of it is the gospel. Because the shape of it is the shape of the universe.

✦

The pattern of death and resurrection is not something God invented to solve the problem of sin. It is not a backup plan activated when Adam fell. The pattern is older than Adam. Older than Earth. Older than the first photon that ever carried the first packet of information through the dark.

The pattern is the shape of God’s own eternal being.

God is the one who pours himself out. That is not a thing God does. That is what God is. When that eternal self-giving showed up in human history on a Friday afternoon in the first century, it did not inaugurate the pattern. It revealed the pattern. It made visible what had always been true about the being at the center of everything.

Which means every lesser instance of the pattern — every marriage that died and rose again, every addict who became more themselves on the other side of the addiction, every career that ended and became a truer calling, every reputation that collapsed and produced a realer human being — every one of those is a small, local translation of the eternal shape.

The pattern keeps appearing in lives that do not know its name. Because the pattern is not a Christian invention. It is the shape reality takes when it is working properly — because the one who made reality has always been cruciform all the way down.

✦

Taylor Swift is not preaching the gospel. But the song she is singing — about carrying the wounds instead of hiding them, about the old self that died and the new self that survived it, about fighting dragons and finding peace on the other side — that song is the gospel’s melody, played on a different instrument.

She is doing what every honest artist eventually ends up doing. She is reaching for the truest thing she can find about her own experience. And the truest thing about her experience turns out to be the truest thing about every experience, because reality has one shape and that shape is the shape of the one who made it.

The old Taylor cannot come to the phone right now. The old Taylor is dead. The new Taylor, with the dragon-marks still visible, is living on the other side of a tomb she did not know she walked through.

The stones would cry out if she kept quiet. But she did not keep quiet. She wrote an album about it. And 102 million people sang along, most of them not knowing what they were singing.

The frequency the universe was tuned to before the first note was ever played is still playing. And the hits, if you listen for them, keep coming.

I tell you, if they keep quiet, the stones will cry out. — Luke 19:40